What Are Priority Debts in Bankruptcy?
Bankruptcy can present a confusing and stressful situation. When you’re dealing with overwhelming debt, understanding which debts take precedence is vital. So, what are priority debts in bankruptcy? These are specific obligations that must be paid before other debts, receiving special treatment in both Chapter 7 and Chapter 13 bankruptcy cases.
If you are thinking about a bankruptcy filing, knowing what priority debts are and how they influence your case is important. This guide will break down what you need to understand about priority debts in bankruptcy. It aims to help you identify potential issues early in the process.
What Are Priority Debts in Bankruptcy?
Priority debts are particular types of financial obligations that bankruptcy law mandates must be settled before other debts. These debts are viewed as more significant and thus are given special consideration during bankruptcy proceedings. The U.S. Bankruptcy Code establishes the system for how these debts are handled, which influences how the case trustee distributes funds from the bankruptcy estate.
In a Chapter 7 bankruptcy, priority debts are paid first from any non-exempt assets available for distribution. Should you file for Chapter 13 bankruptcy, these priority claims must be paid in full through your structured repayment plan. This treatment highlights their importance over other types of unsecured debt.
The policy behind granting certain debts priority status often relates to public welfare or the administration of the bankruptcy system itself. For instance, domestic support obligations are prioritized to protect dependents. Administrative expenses are prioritized so the bankruptcy trustee and other professionals can effectively manage the case.
Types of Priority Debts
The U.S. Bankruptcy Code specifies several categories of priority debts. Understanding these categories is essential as they impact the distribution of assets and the feasibility of a repayment plan. Here are the most common priority debts you might encounter:
1. Domestic Support Obligations
Child support and alimony, often referred to as domestic support obligations, sit at the very top of the priority list. These debts are not dischargeable in bankruptcy and must be paid in full. The law recognizes the critical need to support dependents, even when the payer faces financial hardship.
These support obligations include amounts owed for the care and support of a spouse, former spouse, child, or child’s parent. It’s crucial to stay current on these payments, as failure to do so can lead to severe consequences, even outside of bankruptcy.
2. Administrative Expenses
These are costs directly associated with the administration of the bankruptcy case itself. They include court filing fees, fees for the bankruptcy trustee assigned to your case, and approved attorney fees. Paying these expenses helps the bankruptcy process operate smoothly and efficiently.
The bankruptcy trustee pays these administrative expenses from the bankruptcy estate before most other creditors. This payment structure helps make sure that professionals are willing to manage bankruptcy cases. These expenses are a common priority in nearly all bankruptcy proceedings.
3. Certain Tax Debts
Many types of tax debt are classified as priority debts. This typically includes recent income taxes, often those due within three years of the bankruptcy filing. Property taxes that became a debt before the bankruptcy filing and certain employment taxes also fall into this category.
The government’s claim on these specific taxes takes precedence over many other creditor claims. It is important to distinguish between priority tax debt, which must be paid, and older, nonpriority tax debt, which might be dischargeable under certain conditions. Tax debt rules are intricate, and specific look-back periods apply to determine priority status.
4. Wages, Salaries, and Commissions Owed to Employees
If a business owner files for bankruptcy, any wages, salaries, or commissions owed to employees for services rendered before the filing are considered a priority debt. This protection extends to contributions to employee benefit plans. The law aims to protect workers by helping them receive compensation for their labor.
There are limits on the amount per employee and the timeframe for when these wages were earned to qualify for priority status. This provision primarily applies to business bankruptcies but can also be relevant for individuals who employed others.
5. Deposits by Individuals
If you have accepted deposits from individuals for the purchase, lease, or rental of property, or the purchase of services for personal, family, or household use that were not delivered or provided, these deposits are considered priority debts. This often applies to landlords who have received security deposits from tenants or businesses that took prepayments for goods or services. This type of priority claim is limited to a certain amount per individual.
6. Certain Fines, Penalties, and Forfeitures Owed to Governmental Units
Some fines and penalties owed to governmental entities are also classified as priority debts. However, these must not be punitive in nature but rather compensation for actual monetary loss. This category can be complex, as many governmental fines are non-priority or even non-dischargeable without being priority.
7. Claims for Death or Personal Injury Caused by Operating a Motor Vehicle, Vessel, or Aircraft While Intoxicated
Debts arising from causing death or personal injury while operating a motor vehicle, vessel, or aircraft under the influence of alcohol or drugs are non-dischargeable. These are also given priority status in payment from the bankruptcy estate. This reflects a strong public policy against drunk driving.
Distinguishing Priority Debts from Other Debt Types
To fully grasp the role of priority debts, it’s helpful to understand how they differ from secured debts and general unsecured debts. This distinction is fundamental to how a bankruptcy case proceeds and how creditor claims are handled. The bankruptcy trustee plays a crucial role in categorizing and managing these different debt types.
Secured Debts
Secured debts are those backed by collateral, meaning the creditor has a security interest in a specific piece of property. Mortgages and car loans are common examples of secured debts. If you default on a secured debt, the secured creditor can typically repossess or foreclose on the property.
In bankruptcy, you generally have options for secured debts: you can reaffirm the debt (agree to keep paying it and keep the property), redeem the property (pay its current value in a lump sum), or surrender the property to the creditor. Secured claims are usually paid from the proceeds of their collateral or through ongoing payments.
Unsecured Debts
Unsecured debts are not backed by any collateral. If you default, the creditor cannot seize a specific asset. These debts are further divided into priority unsecured debts and nonpriority unsecured debts.
Priority unsecured debts are the focus of this article. As discussed, these include obligations like certain taxes and domestic support obligations. The bankruptcy trustee pays priority debts after secured creditors (from proceeds of their collateral) but before other unsecured creditors.
Nonpriority unsecured debts, often called general unsecured debts, are at the bottom of the payment hierarchy. Examples include credit card balances, medical bills, and personal loans. In many Chapter 7 cases, general unsecured creditors receive little or no payment, while in Chapter 13, they receive a pro rata share of what’s left after secured and priority debts are accounted for in the repayment plan.
| Debt Category | Backed by Collateral? | Payment Order | Common Examples |
|---|---|---|---|
| Secured Debt | Yes | Highest (from collateral proceeds) | Mortgages, Car Loans |
| Priority Unsecured Debt | No | Middle (before general unsecured) | Certain Taxes, Domestic Support Obligations, Administrative Expenses |
| Nonpriority Unsecured Debt (General Unsecured) | No | Lowest | Credit Card Balances, Medical Bills, Personal Loans |
How Priority Debts Affect Your Bankruptcy Case
The way priority debts are treated varies significantly depending on whether you file for Chapter 7 or Chapter 13 bankruptcy. Understanding these differences is important for choosing the right chapter for your situation. The existence of substantial priority debt can heavily influence this decision.
Priority Debts in Chapter 7 Bankruptcy
In a Chapter 7 bankruptcy, also known as liquidation bankruptcy, a bankruptcy trustee may sell your non-exempt assets to pay creditors. Priority debts are paid first from any available sales proceeds from these assets. If the funds from the bankruptcy estate are insufficient to cover all priority debts within a specific class, they are typically paid on a pro rata basis within that class.
It is very important to remember that most priority debts cannot be discharged in Chapter 7 bankruptcy. This means you will likely still be responsible for paying any remaining balance of these priority unsecured debts after your bankruptcy case concludes. For example, recent income tax debt and domestic support obligations will survive the Chapter 7 discharge.
The bankruptcy trustee has the duty to review creditor claims and pay priority debts according to the order set by the bankruptcy code. If there are no non-exempt assets, then no payments are made by the trustee, and you remain liable for non-dischargeable priority debts.
Priority Debts in Chapter 13 Bankruptcy
Chapter 13 bankruptcy involves creating a repayment plan to pay off your debts over three to five years. In this type of bankruptcy, all priority debts must be paid in full through your Chapter 13 repayment plan. Your plan will not be confirmed (approved) by the bankruptcy court unless it demonstrates full payment of all recognized priority claims.
This requirement can substantially affect your Chapter 13 plan. The necessity to pay priority debts in full might mean you have less disposable income available to pay other debts, like general unsecured debts. It could also result in higher monthly payments or require you to be in a five-year plan rather than a three-year plan.
However, Chapter 13 offers a structured way to handle significant priority debt payment, often allowing you to catch up on arrears like past-due support or taxes over the life of the plan. The trustee in a Chapter 13 case receives your plan payments and distributes them to creditors, making sure the trustee pays priority debts as required.
The Order of Payment in Bankruptcy
The Bankruptcy Code establishes a specific order, or repayment priority, for how creditors get paid. This hierarchy is critical because there often isn’t enough money in the bankruptcy estate to pay all debts in full. The bankruptcy trustee must follow this order strictly.
Generally, secured claims are addressed first, often through payments on the collateral or from the sale of that specific collateral. After secured creditors’ interests are satisfied, the trustee pays priority debts. This means funds from the bankruptcy estate (or from your Chapter 13 plan payments) will go towards priority claims before any money is distributed to nonpriority unsecured creditors.
Finally, if any funds remain after all secured claims and priority debts are paid, general unsecured creditors receive a distribution. This is often a pro rata share, meaning each general unsecured creditor gets a percentage of their claim. In many Chapter 7 cases, these nonpriority unsecured debts receive nothing, highlighting the significance of being a priority creditor.
Strategies for Dealing with Priority Debts
Facing priority debts during a bankruptcy filing can be a source of stress, but there are methods to manage them effectively. Implementing proactive strategies can make the process smoother. It’s important to identify potential issues with these debts early on.
1. Negotiate with Creditors
Before you proceed with a bankruptcy filing, consider trying to negotiate with creditors holding priority debts. Some creditors, particularly for tax debt, may be willing to discuss alternative payment arrangements or settlements. The IRS, for example, has programs like Offer in Compromise or installment agreements for certain tax liabilities.
While negotiating domestic support obligations arrears can be more challenging, it’s sometimes possible to work out a payment schedule with the recipient or the state enforcement agency. Addressing these debts proactively can sometimes lessen the pressure.
2. Consider Chapter 13 Bankruptcy
If you have substantial priority debts that you cannot pay off quickly, Chapter 13 bankruptcy often presents a more manageable solution than Chapter 7. Chapter 13 allows you to repay these debts over an extended period of three to five years. This structured debt payment approach can provide significant relief.
This option allows you to catch up on obligations like past-due child support or recent income taxes without the immediate threat of aggressive collection actions. The repayment plan provides a clear path for resolving these important debts owed.
3. Prioritize Your Payments
If you are struggling to pay all your debts, concentrate on making payments towards your priority debts first. Failing to pay these debts can lead to severe consequences. For instance, non-payment of domestic support can result in wage garnishment, driver’s license suspension, or even jail time, while unpaid tax debt can lead to levies and liens.
Understanding the repayment priority and consequences associated with each debt will help you allocate your limited funds more effectively before and during bankruptcy. This focus is important for your financial well-being.
4. Seek Professional Help
Bankruptcy law, particularly the rules surrounding priority debts, is intricate and can be confusing. It is highly recommended to consult with an experienced bankruptcy attorney. A lawyer can guide you through the process, help you understand your options, and develop a strategy for your specific situation.
An attorney can help accurately identify all your priority debts, make sure they are correctly listed in your bankruptcy paperwork, and explain how the bankruptcy trustee will likely handle these claims. This professional guidance can be invaluable for a successful bankruptcy outcome and can help you identify potential pitfalls related to debts owed like support income taxes.
Identifying Priority Debts: A Practical Approach
Correctly identifying all your priority debts is a critical first step in any bankruptcy case. Mistakes or omissions can lead to complications, denial of discharge for certain debts, or problems with your repayment plan. You’ll need to gather specific documents and pay close attention to detail.
Start by collecting all relevant financial documents. This includes recent tax returns (federal, state, and local), any notices or letters from the IRS or other tax authorities, and court orders related to child support or alimony. If you own a business, gather payroll records and information on employee benefit plans.
Your bankruptcy petition and schedules require you to list all your debts, classifying them correctly. This is where you’ll distinguish between secured debt, priority unsecured debt, and nonpriority unsecured debt. Working with a bankruptcy attorney can be very helpful here, as they understand the legal definitions and timeframes that determine a debt’s priority status.
The bankruptcy trustee also plays a role in verifying creditor claims, including those asserted as priority. Creditors must file a proof of claim to receive payment from the bankruptcy estate. The trustee reviews these claims to make certain they are valid and correctly classified before the trustee pays priority claims or any other claims.
Common Misconceptions About Priority Debts
Several common misunderstandings exist regarding priority debts in bankruptcy. Clarifying these misconceptions can help you approach your bankruptcy case with more accurate information. It’s important to separate fact from fiction concerning these significant financial obligations.
Misconception 1: All Tax Debts Are Priority Debts
While many tax debts indeed qualify as priority debts, it’s incorrect to assume all of them do. Generally, income taxes from the last three years (subject to specific timing rules like the 240-day rule and the 2-year rule for filing returns) are priority. Older income tax debts, or taxes for which returns were filed late, might be classified as nonpriority unsecured debts and could potentially be discharged in bankruptcy if all conditions are met.
Other taxes, like trust fund taxes (e.g., payroll taxes withheld from employees), are almost always priority and non-dischargeable regardless of age. The rules for tax debt in bankruptcy are among the most complicated, so professional advice is often necessary to determine the correct status of each tax liability.
Misconception 2: Student Loans Are Priority Debts
Student loans are frequently, and mistakenly, believed to be priority debts because they are notoriously difficult to discharge in bankruptcy. However, student loans are typically classified as nonpriority unsecured debts. Their difficult-to-discharge nature stems from a separate provision in the Bankruptcy Code requiring a showing of “undue hardship,” not from being a priority debt.
This means that while you might still owe student loans after bankruptcy, they don’t get paid ahead of other general unsecured creditors from the bankruptcy estate in a Chapter 7, nor do they require full payment in a Chapter 13 unless you choose to pay them more through your plan (which is often limited).
Misconception 3: Priority Debts Can Never Be Discharged
While it is true that most common priority debts, like recent income taxes and domestic support obligations, cannot be discharged through bankruptcy, there are some exceptions or clarifications. For instance, as mentioned, certain older tax debts that lose their priority status might become dischargeable if they meet specific criteria.
Furthermore, in a Chapter 13 bankruptcy, while priority debts must be paid in full through the plan, the underlying obligation is effectively managed and resolved by the completion of the plan. The “discharge” in Chapter 13 covers debts paid under the plan, providing a way to handle these otherwise non-dischargeable debts in a structured manner.
The Impact of Priority Debts on Your Financial Future
Understanding your priority debts is fundamental for your financial future, particularly if you are looking at bankruptcy as an option. These debts have far-reaching consequences. Their presence and amount can shape the course of your bankruptcy and your post-bankruptcy life.
1. They Affect Your Bankruptcy Options
The total amount and specific types of priority debts you owe can heavily influence whether Chapter 7 or Chapter 13 bankruptcy is more suitable for your circumstances. If you have substantial priority debts that won’t be discharged in Chapter 7 (like recent tax debt or support arrears), you might find Chapter 13 to be a more practical choice, as it allows you to pay these debts over time.
Attempting a Chapter 7 with large, non-dischargeable priority debts might leave you in a difficult financial position post-bankruptcy. Conversely, if your priority debts are minimal, Chapter 7 might offer a quicker path to a fresh start if you meet the eligibility criteria.
2. They Can Extend Your Bankruptcy Process
In a Chapter 13 bankruptcy, the legal requirement to pay off all priority debts in full can extend the duration of your repayment plan. Chapter 13 plans last from three to five years. If significant priority debt payments are needed, your plan will likely be for the full five years to accommodate these payments.
This means you will be under the supervision of the bankruptcy court and the Chapter 13 trustee for a longer period. While this provides a structured way to resolve these debts, it’s a longer commitment than a typical Chapter 7 case, which usually concludes in a few months.
3. They Can Impact Your Fresh Start
Since many priority debts survive a Chapter 7 bankruptcy or must be paid in full through a Chapter 13 plan, they can affect your ability to achieve a truly “fresh” financial start. You will need to incorporate any ongoing obligations for non-discharged priority debts into your post-bankruptcy budget. This is true even if the bankruptcy trustee pays some portion of these debts during the case.
Failure to account for these continuing payments can lead to renewed financial stress. Careful planning is essential to manage any remaining priority debt payment obligations after your bankruptcy case is officially closed.
Conclusion
Priority debts play a very important role in any bankruptcy proceeding. Knowing what are priority debts in bankruptcy can empower you to make better decisions about your financial path forward. These debts, including crucial obligations such as domestic support obligations, recent income tax debt, and administrative expenses related to the bankruptcy case, receive preferential treatment under the bankruptcy code in both Chapter 7 and Chapter 13 consumer bankruptcies.
If you are thinking about filing for bankruptcy, it’s vital to assess your priority debts with care. They can significantly influence the outcome of your bankruptcy case and your financial stability after bankruptcy. While managing priority debts can present challenges, bankruptcy is a legal tool that offers a route to financial recovery.
With thorough planning, accurate information, and often the guidance of a legal professional familiar with the trustee program and creditor claims, you can address these debts. This understanding allows you to work towards a more secure financial future, even if it involves making arrangements for paying priority obligations. Remember to review any privacy policy if consulting online resources or tools like a bankruptcy quiz, and always prioritize obtaining reliable legal advice.
The Law Office of William Waldner offers FREE consultations. Call or text us today to set yours up at 212-244-2882.